Back to Where Tom Recently Ate main page

Smokey Q
I wanted to love you

9/13/04

The mere thought of good ‘cue’ in Midtown excites me. And I arrived at Smokey Q with much anticipation after reading food writer, Cynthia Wong’s (Creative Loafing) glowing review, but still cognizant of the fact that inconsistencies plague most, if not all, ‘cue’ joints in town.

That being said, I’d also like to say that Cynthia Wong, in my opinion, is truly one of the most talented and entertaining food writer’s I’ve ever come across.

We entered Smokey Q greeted by stacked layers of smoke and the pleasant reverberation of blues bouncing from one brick-walled corner to another – I really dig the setting. Too bad they don’t sell beer, though.

Unfortunately, most of what I dig about Smokey Q starts and ends with its ambience. My three visits yielded Pork as memorable as the average Bush speech. Yawn.

St Louis Ribs were mediocre at best. That is, when they weren’t tough and stringy, the meat often strongly gripped the bone and wouldn't let go. I like for succulent, tender meat to effortlessly slip right off the bone.

The food woes at Smokey Q are even more evident in their side orders. In fact, I’ve come to the conclusion that sides here are actually worse than those offered at Pig-N-Chik. Previously, I didn’t think that was even remotely possible. Beans taste as if from a can and onion rings, doused with parmesan, are limp and salty – I’d prefer a deeper fried ring – 86 the parmesan.

I was anxious to try the Beer Can Chicken, but they told me they wouldn’t have any available for a few hours. A real let down to say the least. However, the brisket was commendable. Actually, the brisket appears to be the highlight of all their offerings. No, it’s not in the same league with Champ’s BBQ in Smyrna but I wouldn’t kick it out of bed, or even off my plate. I like the fact that they leave a thin layer of clinging fat, just enough to flavor the slender strips.

Smokey Q offers several different sauces from Carolina mustard to the sweet and tangy stuff. I prefer to mix the sweet and tangy with their NC vinegar. Unfortunately, the NC vinegar doesn’t have enough body to stand on its own.

Is there any chance in hell we’ll ever see the day good ‘cue’ comes to Midtown?



Price Range: $4.99-$16.99

Key Notes:
The pork will make you yawn
The ribs are very inconsistent
Go for the brisket but stay clear of side orders
No alcohol served

554-A Piedmont Ave., Midtown Tel: 404-897-3588


Advertise | Contact Us | Privacy Statement

©2002 - 2006. All Rights Reserved
Developed by Tom Maicon